Defamation is a criminal case in India
Defamation cases come
regularly to the court. Most cases are of political leaders. Defamation is
categorized under criminal cases in India.
This law imposed by British works
this way –
The criminal proceedings
happening after the registration of defamation case was challenged by Rahul
Gandhi, Arvind Kejriwal and Subramanian Swami in Supreme Court. Under Indian
penal code 1860 chapter 21, section 499 and 500 have been challenged many times
in past. It has been stated that defamation should come under Deewani or
madness case and not a criminal case.
This would motivate the right to speak and voices of people working for public
welfare would not be stifled.
The central government wants
to keep this law as it is. A committee of two judges have denied the petitions
regarding the same. Judged Deepak Mishra and PC Pant denied the petition of
changing the law and stated that it is legal and constitutional right to punish
the defamation criminals. They also stated that right to speak and freedom
should not cross its limits. Those whose rights have been compromised also have
the full right to live respectfully. Judges have given suggestions to the
lawyers that they should take care when passing summons on personal defamation
complaints.
The whole world sees these
cases as Deewani or madness cases except India. Jayalalithaa
government in Tamil Nadu have petitioned more than 100 defamation cases against
journalists and opposition party candidates.
It is important to know what
Defamation is. Defamation is a kind of legal mistake which causes problems on a
person’s respect and character. His character is demoralized without proper
witness and proof. Written or oral defamation are both under the slander
category. When a person puts blame on another person with negativity and hidden
agendas towards other, this comes under defamation.
If a person’s respect is
reduced or his/her work is affected badly by such allegations then it comes
under defamation.
There are some cases in which
there is no defamation law to be established. These are –
· 1) If anything which
is true and is brought to notice for public welfare.
· 2) Any working of court or publishing their right judgment.
Under Section 500 there is
the provision of sentence for defamation.
A person found guilty of defaming
somebody will be jailed for two years or will be fined or both. Also, the lawyer has to present the facts
correctly and prove that there has been defamation and the reason behind it.
This law was made in our country by the British to stifle the voices of people
and their rights. The fourth president of America James Edison said that “People have a right to censor the
government and not vice versa”.
Fact – In Azerbaijan when the defamation case is proved then, the criminal is charged with 500 times of
his nominal salary as fine.
Nandita jha advocate Delhi High Court |
Source - Nandita jha advocate Delhi High Court in DB News
No comments:
Post a Comment